*
JONAH REMEMBERS THE WHALE
A rib arched above me.
Below the lungs blossomed,
the manifold cilia bowed.
I woke to humming, gurgling,
the mighty inner tides.
Lulled by the slush-slush
of the great whale blood,
I felt washed clean of ego,
one with enveloping life.
No doomsday
deadlines, no burning
graven images.
My heart murmur fell still
next to the giant heart
that tolled Dive — dive —
Then the command: “Out! Out!
Preach judgment unto
Nineveh!” Across the briny
irony of waves, weeping I waded
to loneliness again.
Now when twilight
grows on the roofs,
hushes the palm trees
and bazaars, and the wind
in the tamarind grove
sighs like an old man,
I sit on the sand and dream
of the muffled green sun
of the sea; I ride the wild
forgiveness of the whale.
~ Oriana
*
Balzac would supposedly leave parties to go back to his writing table with the words, "I must rejoin the real world!”
On his deathbed, in a state of delirium, he called out, "Only Blanchon can save me now!”
Blanchon being the medical student character in his novel Père Goriot.
(my thanks to M. Iossel)
*
THE TRAGEDY OF JACK KEROUAC
Jack Kerouac became famous for freedom and died trapped by the version of himself the world refused to let him escape.
On the Road made him the voice of a generation, but it also turned his private restlessness into a public obligation.
The book did not save him. It fixed him in place.
Kerouac grew up poor, Catholic, and grieving. His older brother died when Jack was four, and the loss never left him. Writing became confession, prayer, and escape. He chased motion not for pleasure, but to outrun stillness, where memory waited.
What Kerouac had written as exhaustion and yearning was sold as a lifestyle.
This mattered because Kerouac was not built for celebrity.
He was shy, anxious, deeply attached to his mother, and emotionally fragile. Fame demanded performance. Interviews demanded slogans. Readers wanted the road forever. Kerouac wanted to go home.
The machine did not care.
Publishers pushed him to repeat himself. Journalists mocked him when he failed to sound revolutionary on command. Television appearances turned cruel. He drank to quiet the gap between who he was and who he was expected to be.
Alcohol became structure.
While the culture celebrated freedom, Kerouac retreated into isolation, bitterness, and dependency. He watched others turn his work into movements, careers, and myths while his own life narrowed. The man who wrote about motion stopped moving forward.
By his forties, his body was failing. His liver collapsed under years of drinking. He died in 1969 at forty-seven, back in his mother’s house, far from the road that made him famous.
Jack Kerouac is remembered as a symbol of liberation.
That image misses the cost.
His real story is about what happens when a system turns a moment of honesty into an identity you are never allowed to outgrow.
The shock is not that freedom destroyed him.
It is that the world demanded he keep performing it long after it stopped being true.
~ True Stories, Facebook
*
MIDDLE ENGLISH
If you traveled to the 1300s, you’d have to scrape your throat to say thought, pronounce the 'k' in knight, and realize that someone calling you "nice" actually meant you were a fool.
The shift from the Germanic Old English of Beowulf to the Middle English of Chaucer was one of the most violent linguistic transformations in history, and it created a dialect filled with unfamiliar sounds and deceptive vocabulary.
The root of this transformation was the Norman Conquest of 1066. The new ruling class spoke French, while the peasantry continued speaking Old English. Over three centuries, these languages crashed into each other. Approximately 10,000 French words flooded the English vocabulary, specifically concerning law, government, and high society—which is why English has Germanic words for animals (cow, pig) but French words for the meat served at a feast (beef, pork).
During this mixing period, English grammar collapsed in on itself. Old English relied on complex suffixes attached to nouns and verbs to indicate who was doing what to whom. When interacting with Norse-speaking Vikings and French-speaking rulers, English speakers gradually dropped these confusing endings to make trade and daily interaction easier. Stripped of its inflectional suffixes, English had to adopt a strict Subject-Verb-Object word order to remain understandable.
A time traveler would immediately struggle with the pronunciation. Middle English was spoken before the "Great Vowel Shift" of the 15th century. Vowels sounded closer to modern German or Spanish: "house" was pronounced hoos, and "bite" sounded like beet. Furthermore, there were no silent letters. A speaker pronounced the "w" in write and the "l" in half. The "gh" in words like night required that harsh guttural scrape at the back of the throat, similar to the Scottish loch.
Even if a modern speaker could decipher the sounds, the vocabulary would be treacherous due to "false friends." Aside from nice meaning foolish, if someone said they were "starving," it simply meant they were dyåing by any means, not necessarily from hunger.
Reading it would be just as challenging. With no dictionaries and low literacy rates, spelling was entirely phonetic and tied to regional accents. A single word could be spelled dozens of ways depending on who was holding the quill; the word "through" was recorded as thurgh, thorow, and drough.
~ SepiaGlyphs, Quora
*
CATALAN VS SPANISH: WHY THEY ARE NOT MUTUALLY COMPREHENSIBLE
Despite sharing the Iberian Peninsula for centuries, Catalan isn't a linguistic sibling to Spanish. It actually shares far more of its DNA with the languages of southern France.
Because of this, the two languages are not mutually intelligible; they belong to completely different branches of the Romance language family tree.
The root of this divide is historical geography. While Spanish is an Ibero-Romance language, Catalan is classified as a Gallo-Romance or Occitano-Romance language. After the fall of the Roman Empire, the Iberian Peninsula was largely conquered by the Moors. However, the northeastern corner (modern-day Catalonia) was absorbed into the Frankish Empire to act as a buffer zone known as the Marca Hispanica. Because of this political and cultural alignment, the Vulgar Latin spoken in the region evolved under heavy influence from the territories to the north, tying Catalan's development to Occitan and French rather than to Spanish.
These distinct evolutionary paths created massive barriers to mutual intelligibility, most notably in how the languages sound. Spanish has a straightforward five-vowel system (a, e, i, o, u), making it highly phonetic and open. Catalan, in contrast, features an eight-vowel system that includes open and closed versions of 'e' and 'o', as well as the neutral "schwa" sound common in English but absent in Spanish. Furthermore, Catalan frequently drops the final vowels of words, resulting in abrupt, heavy consonant clusters. For example, the word for "bridge" is puente in Spanish but pont in Catalan.
Vocabulary also diverges significantly because the two languages frequently pull from different Latin roots.
Window: The Spanish word is ventana, derived from the Latin word for wind. The Catalan word is finestra, which directly mirrors the French fenêtre and Italian finestra.
Cheese: The Spanish word is queso, while the Catalan word is formatge (similar to the French fromage).
To speak: The Spanish verb is hablar, whereas the Catalan verb is parlar.
Grammatically, Catalan possesses a highly unusual quirk that confuses many Spanish speakers: a past tense formed using the present tense of the verb "to go" (anar) combined with an infinitive. In Spanish, "I went to buy" translates to fui a comprar. In Catalan, vaig comprar literally translates to "I go to buy," but it actually means "I bought." This specific construction can completely disorient a Spanish speaker trying to follow a Catalan narrative.
Ultimately, the combination of a broader vowel inventory, dense consonant endings, distinct root vocabulary, and entirely different grammatical structures means that the two languages evolved in parallel rather than in tandem. Without prior exposure or dedicated study, a Spanish speaker cannot naturally understand spoken Catalan. ~ SepiaGlyph, Quora
*
THE ORIGINS OF THE ETRUSCANS
In 2021, DNA from 82 ancient tombs settled a 2,500-year-old debate over Etruscan origins. Genetically, they were nearly identical to early Romans, yet they spoke an unrelated language.
Before the rise of Rome, this sophisticated civilization dominated central Italy. Ancient Greek historians were split on where they came from: Herodotus claimed they were refugees from Anatolia, while Dionysius of Halicarnassus insisted they were indigenous.
The 2021 genetic study, published in the journal Science, proved Dionysius right. By sequencing genomes from remains spanning 800 BCE to 1000 CE, researchers confirmed the Etruscans were indigenous. They did not migrate from Anatolia or the Near East. Like other local Iron Age populations, the Etruscans possessed a large proportion of genetic ancestry from the Yamnaya—pastoralists from the Pontic-Caspian steppe who swept into Europe during the Bronze Age.
This discovery solved the biological mystery but deepened a linguistic one. The Steppe migrants are widely believed to have brought Indo-European languages to Europe. While the Latins adopted these new languages, the Etruscans somehow retained their ancestral, non-Indo-European tongue (part of the Tyrsenian language family) despite thousands of years of extensive genetic mixing. Their language vanished only when they were culturally absorbed into the Roman Republic.
Previous attempts to solve the Etruscan puzzle using DNA had stumbled by comparing fragmented ancient samples to modern Tuscans. The 2021 study revealed why this earlier method failed: the genetic makeup of central Italy did not stay frozen in time. During the Roman Empire, the local population underwent a major genetic shift as slaves, soldiers, and merchants from the eastern Mediterranean flooded the peninsula. Centuries later, after the fall of Rome, Germanic migrations brought a surge of northern European DNA. By sequencing remains directly from untouched ancient tombs rather than relying on modern descendants, researchers bypassed two thousand years of demographic upheaval to reveal the Etruscans as they actually were.
~ SepiaGlyphs, Quora
Etruscan tombs: the earthen tumuli of the Banditaccia
Robert Sprinkle:
The irony is that the Etruscans built Rome up from hillside farms to a city in order to protect themselves from the Greeks making their way up the peninsula. I guess it worked a little too well.

*
THE GOTHIC KINGDOMS AFTER THE FALL OF ROME
Seizing the heart of the Roman Empire was a death sentence. The Germanic kingdoms in its southern provinces were annihilated, while those in the north built modern Europe.
In Italy, the Ostrogoths established a powerful state under Theodoric the Great, who ruled from Ravenna and attempted to fuse Roman administration with Gothic military might. He built a monumental stone mausoleum for himself in the Roman style. However, shortly after his death, the Byzantine Emperor Justinian launched a war of reconquest. By 553, the Ostrogothic kingdom was destroyed, and its people were absorbed into the local population. The Vandals in North Africa met a swift fate; Byzantine forces dismantled their kingdom in a single campaign in 534.
The Mausoleum of Theodoric stands in Ravenna, Italy. The Ostrogothic king Theodoric the Great built the monument in 520 AD, shortly before the Byzantine Empire destroyed his kingdom.
Further west, the Visigoths carved out a realm spanning southwestern Gaul and the Iberian Peninsula. The Visigothic Kingdom survived the Byzantine resurgence and endured for centuries. They developed a sophisticated legal code and converted to Catholic Christianity, deeply integrating with the local Hispano-Roman population. Their downfall came from the south. In 711, the expanding Umayyad Caliphate crossed the Strait of Gibraltar and defeated the Visigothic army, absorbing nearly the entire peninsula into the Islamic world.
The Franks, expanding from the lower Rhine, were the most successful of the northern kingdoms. Under the Merovingian and later Carolingian dynasties, they conquered rival Germanic tribes—including the Burgundians and the Lombards—and established a vast empire under Charlemagne. This Frankish realm eventually fractured along linguistic lines, laying the geographic and cultural groundwork for modern France and Germany.
Across the English Channel, the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes established a series of competing kingdoms in former Roman Britain. Shielded by the sea from both Byzantine and Umayyad expansion, these Anglo-Saxon kingdoms gradually coalesced. By the 10th century, they unified into the single Kingdom of England, a political entity that survived even after its ruling class was replaced during the Norman Conquest of 1066.
Giovanni B:
What is really surprising about the Mausoleum is its roof—a single piece of limestone weighing 290 metric tons.
Oriana:
Zbigniew Herbert wrote a poem that for me came to symbolize the various tribes that followed the fall of the Roman Empire:
THE LONGOBARDS
A great cold blows from the Longobards
they sit tight in the saddle of the passes
as in steep chairs
in the left hand they hold the dawn
in the right hand a whip
glaciers
they whip beasts of burden
fires
the cracking of stars
ashes
the pendulum of the stirrup
clots of alien blood
black and hard as flint
under their fingernails
under their eyelids
the burning of spruce
barking of a horse
ashes
on steep hillsides a snake
twines the shield
straight-backed they walk from the north
sleepless almost blind
women rock reddish children over the fire
a great cold blows from the Longobards
their shadows burn the grass
as they fly into a valley
crying their elongated
nothing nothing nothing
~ Zbigniew Herbert, tr Oriana Ivy
*
STALISNISM: HEAVY INDUSTRY VERSUS CONSUMER GOODS
When Joseph Stalin consolidated power in the late 1920s, the Soviet Union was decades behind the capitalist West. He implemented a strict command economy through Five-Year Plans, directing national energy into heavy industry like steel, coal, and armaments.
To fund this explosion of industry, Stalin relied on forced agricultural collectivization. The state seized private farms and extracted grain at gunpoint, selling it abroad to purchase foreign machinery and feeding the rapidly growing urban workforce. This extraction triggered famines like the Holodomor, but it generated the necessary capital.
This hyper-centralized mobilization achieved its specific goal. It allowed the USSR to build an industrial base past the Ural Mountains, outproduce Nazi Germany in tanks and artillery during World War II, and later develop nuclear weapons, cementing its superpower status.
However, the rigid mechanics of Stalinism eventually caused its own collapse. A command economy is effective at scaling up known technologies, like building tractor factories, but it struggles to innovate. Without market signals or competition, Soviet factory managers simply met state quotas by producing outdated goods. The system completely missed the information technology revolution of the 1970s and 1980s.
Collectivization permanently crippled Soviet agriculture. Farmers had no incentive to care for state-owned land, turning a nation that was once a major grain exporter into an importer forced to buy millions of tons of wheat from the United States.
Furthermore, Stalin’s rapid growth relied heavily on terror and forced labor. When his successors dismantled the mass terror apparatus to create a functioning peacetime society, the economy lost its primary motivator. Without the threat of the Gulag, productivity stagnated.
The Soviet economy remained a permanent war economy, funneling up to a quarter of its GDP into the military while citizens stood in hours-long lines for basic necessities like fresh meat and winter boots.*
WHY CANNED FISH WAS SO ABUNDANT IN SOVIET STORES
Soviet grocery stores featured endless aisles stocked entirely with canned fish and three-liter jars of apple juice. They weren’t a sign of plenty—they were props used to hide empty shelves.
The Soviet economy operated on five-year plans dictated by the state planning committee, Gosplan. Production was driven by numerical quotas rather than consumer demand. If the plan mandated the production of 10 million tons of canned fish, factories operated around the clock to meet that exact target, regardless of whether citizens wanted that much fish or if there was bread to pair it with. Factory managers were rewarded for raw output, meaning they favored producing bulk items that were easy to manufacture in high volumes.
During the Cold War, the USSR invested in a distant-water fishing fleet to secure a cheap source of protein. These factory ships caught large quantities of fish, such as pollock and saury, and processed them at sea. Because the Soviet Union lacked a reliable cold-chain logistics network, perishable goods like fresh meat or dairy often spoiled before reaching stores. Canning was the only way to ensure the protein survived the journey across the world's largest country.
Vintage Soviet-era tins of canned fish sit on display at the Aral Sea Museum in Mo’ynoq.
The abundance of juice in three-liter jars followed a similar logic, compounded by the Soviet pursuit of economic self-sufficiency. The USSR lacked the hard foreign currency required to import tropical fruits like oranges or bananas. However, the country had sprawling apple orchards and endless forests of birch trees. State-run bottling plants churned out birch juice—a lightly sweetened sap—and apple juice because the raw materials were domestic, cheap, and abundant. Sealed in heavy glass jars, the juice could sit on an unrefrigerated shelf indefinitely.
The final piece of the puzzle was the phenomenon of defitsit (deficit). When desirable, scarce goods like quality sausage or fresh fruit appeared in a store, shoppers bought them instantly or employees diverted them to the black market. What remained on the shelves were the overproduced, non-perishable items nobody needed to hoard. To mask the shortages, store managers took their surplus of unwanted canned fish or birch juice and spread it out, creating geometric displays that spanned entire empty aisles. ~ Sepia Glyphs, Quora
*
CHINA IS FINALLY REDUCING EMISSIONS
China's economy has seen monumental growth over the past three decades. So have its CO2 emissions, which ballooned nearly fivefold from 1990 to 2024.
China's global share of CO2 also jumped from around 10% to more than 30% during this period, the largest global increase.
China plays a "pivotal role" in the world's fight against climate change not only because it is the largest CO2 emitter, but also because its emissions have grown at the fastest rate.
Some believe the watershed moment is already upon China. The country's carbon emissions reached their highest level in 2024 and fell in 2025, according to data from Climate Action Tracker (CAT). CAT predicts China's carbon emissions will decrease by about 18% by 2035.
A separate analysis by the Center for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), a Finnish think tank, found that China's CO2 emissions have remained flat or falling since March 2024, bar a small rise in early 2026.
The rapid decline is not only driven by the shrinking output of some heavy industries, but also by China's "enormous expansion" of clean energy and growing use of electricity – instead of fossil fuels – to power machines, vehicles and devices.
What is more important, however, is whether China's emissions will drop quickly after the peak or remain at a high level. Even a 1% reduction would have a profound impact on global climate action.
Renewable revolution
Under China's strong policy steer, massive wind and solar power stations have risen in the desert and vast arrays of solar panels have been mounted on rooftops. Gigantic wind turbines are harnessing the power of strong storms off the coast of China.
In 2023 alone, China installed 217 gigawatts (GW) of solar panels, more than the US had installed in its entire history. It repeated this feat in 2024 and 2025.
A renewable spree has prevented China from falling back onto fossil fuels, even though it needs to generate more and more electricity each year – for air-conditioning, EVs and data centers.
The share of China's electricity generated by coal has continued to shrink rapidly. By 2025, coal generated around 54% of its electricity and this further dipped to a historic low of 49.7% between January and June of 2026, according to China's National Energy Administration.
Wind and solar power made up 25% of China's power generation in the first half of the year, according to government data. China aims to generate 30% of its electricity using wind and solar by 2030.
One of the main drivers of emissions' reductions, though, is the decline in oil consumption in transport following the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and the rapid electrification of this sector.
The rise of EVs
China has left the world in the dust when it comes to the adoption of EVs and the impact on emissions is already starting to show. Between January and June 2026, China's fleet of electric cars, buses and trucks helped avoid the use of 36 million tons of oil, according to CREA – equivalent to half the UK's annual oil consumption.
In July, more than six in every 10 new cars sold in China were "new-energy vehicles", a term used by the Chinese government to include pure electric, plug-in hybrids and fuel cell vehicles powered by alternative fuels like hydrogen. EV sales in China are expected to reach 14.3 million in 2026, nearly three times more than in Europe and 12 times higher than in the US, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA).
This extraordinary growth has been largely driven by the surge of electric heavy-duty trucks. The government requires companies in dozens of industries to use a certain share of these trucks in transport fleets, or face production curtailments on heavily polluted days.
Battery boom
Batteries are crucial for China's net-zero ambition: they power its fleet of EVs and store surplus electricity for later use.
China is the world leader in battery energy storage systems, accounting for more than half of the global capacity by the end of 2025. These systems receive and store surplus renewable power, sending it back to the grid during periods of maximum energy demand.
"They are a key component for a future grid that uses a higher and higher portion of wind and solar power," says Yang Biqing, an analyst at Ember, such as by storing daytime solar power and releasing it to the grid in the evening.
For the past few years, China has required wind and solar stations to build or purchase a certain amount of energy-storage capacity to help the grid absorb the electricity they generate. This policy, coupled with the falling price of lithium batteries, has kickstarted a remarkable transition.
By the end of March 2026, China had installed nearly 150GW of energy-storage capacity that used lithium batteries, more than the rest of the world combined, according to Ember. China aims to build more than 180GW of new energy-storage capacity, primarily those using batteries, by 2027.
Still, China's energy-storage stations are currently severely underused, according to Ember.
Boosting their usage – and by extension their profitability – will require more fundamental changes to China's power grid and power-trading system, which were designed to serve coal.
China's heavy investment in clean energy and EVs has begun to bear fruit, changing its power structure and bending its carbon emissions' trajectory in fundamental ways.
But for many, a key question remains: will China's emissions rebound once more if its stagnant economy starts to pick up? Coal is deeply embedded in all aspects of China's economy – decoupling the two is "the biggest challenge" the superpower faces in its bid to reach net zero.
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20261106-china-is-finally-slowing-its-ballooning-emissions
*
HOW THE HORSE MADE THE STATE
Civilization wasn’t made possible by grain, but by transportation – and the conquest it enabled, from the steppe to the sea
Transportation is the backbone of civilization, which is why controlling the Strait of Hormuz grants global leverage. Because oil fuels more than 90 per cent of global transit, the source of this power lies not in the waterway, but in the control of global mobility. Halting all oil supplies paralyzes virtually all transport, communication and supply lines: cities collapse, states disintegrate, societies break down and populations die off, throwing humanity back to the pre-industrial age.
Without transport animals, humanity would still be back in the Stone Age.
No city or state can exist without transportation, for there can be no concentration of population and resources. No transportation means no extrahuman transportation, leaving walking and carrying as the only means of transit. This baseline determined the size and structure of human communities. Production was limited to what could be carried home, circumscribing the areas where humans could settle and colonize. Production capacity and resource availability kept communities small, forcing them to split and disperse. Because size dictates structure, small meant undifferentiated and egalitarian. Ultimately, the inherent limit of the physical capability of travel and portage formed a natural immunity to inequality: it kept communities small, egalitarian and autonomous, leaving their lands beyond conquest.
As long as this constraint existed, communities resembled those of the Amazon Basin or the New Guinea Highlands. The domestication of animals and the invention of boats liberated humanity, making long-distance mobility possible. With this newfound capacity, communities no longer needed to fit their immediate environments; instead, they could build cities and integrate expansive areas – all roads lead to Rome. Transportation – not grain – is what brought the state and civilization into existence, and what continues to maintain them. Let’s examine this power by looking from the present back to the origin of the state.
Whoever rules the waves rules the world! Without its navy and air force, the United States cannot command global reach or project power worldwide. The same was true of European colonial empires; ultimately, warships and gunboats forged them. In earlier periods, Vikings built their empire on longships, Aztecs on canoes, Egyptians on riverboats, and Romans, Greeks and Phoenicians on galleys.
Conquering the world on horseback is easy, as the saying goes. On land, equids – donkeys and horses – forged states and civilizations, while the llama did the same for the Inca. Ur’s kunga chariots projected the military might of Mesopotamian cities, and the Abydos donkeys demonstrated their vital role in early Egyptian kingship. By the end of the 3rd millennium BCE, Central Eurasian nomads were entombing entire horse chariots – the high-tech, high-value war machines of their time – to honor their kings in Sintashta (Southern Urals). Horse chariots later symbolized the power of the Shang and the Zhou; the latter deployed 4,000 chariots to overwhelm the former in 1046 BCE.
‘The rider appears on the stage of history like a new breed of man’ – a centaur, as the German sociologist Alexander Rüstow put it in the 1950s. Eurasian nomads had long bred their mounts into the modern domestic horse, paving the way for an age of empires that would fundamentally reshape the world. Horses dominated human history for nearly four millennia.
Even for maritime powers, horses remained key to conquest; from Carthage to the British, all relied on horses for inland expansion. Francisco Pizarro’s conquest of the Inca is a prime illustration of the power of horses against an essentially pedestrian empire built on llama transportation. Horses also enabled the Comanche in North America to forge their empire and compete with European powers for nearly a century.

Comanche warriors, 1892
The Comanche Empire? Did they actually have grain to build a state? No, they had no grain – nor any agriculture, for that matter. Horse husbandry and bison hunting sustained their livelihood. In fact, all the Eurasian steppe powers – including the Mongols – relied on pastoralism. What they enjoyed most was an abundance of extrahuman transportation; what they lacked most was agricultural produce. Ultimately, building a state does not require grain, but it does demand extrahuman transportation.
Look at the political geography of the Roman and Mongol empires: the Romans could reach where ships could reach, and the Mongols could reach where horses could reach. The same is true of European colonial empires; it all comes down to the power of extrahuman transportation. Donkeys, horses and all other herd animals are the creations of pastoralists. Extrahuman transportation made the state and civilization possible; this places pastoralism at the origin of the state and civilization, and the Eurasian steppe at the center of human history.
*
While scholars critique world history for its Eurocentric bias, its conceptual framework and narrative are profoundly Sinocentric. This is because the origin of the state – and consequently the birth of civilization – is the question that shapes our vision of world history. The latest authoritative iteration of this view is James C Scott’s Against the Grain: A Deep History of the Earliest States (2017), along with his The Art of Not Being Governed (2009). ‘The Origin of the State: Land Productivity or Appropriability’ by Joram Mayshar and colleagues is its economic restatement.
Scott, readers might counter, focuses almost exclusively on Mesopotamia and rarely mentions China. Yet his underlying framework actually rearticulates the paradigm established by the American Orientalist Owen Lattimore’s influential work, Inner Asian Frontiers of China (1940). Precisely for this reason, Scott not only frequently mentions ‘the loess soils along the Yellow River’, but also, directly quoting Lattimore, claims that ‘irrigation was spectacularly rewarding in the loess core of ancient China’.
Lattimore sought to legitimize the Republic of China’s claims over Mongolia, Manchukuo, Tibet and Eastern Turkestan. To this end, he advanced the grain thesis to locate the origins of statehood and civilization in the Yellow River Valley, positioning China as the Cradle of the East.
By mapping Frederick Jackson Turner’s American frontier thesis onto the region, Lattimore framed China as the civilized center and reduced the aforementioned territories to ‘Inner Asia’ – a mere geohistorical frontier akin to the American West. In doing so, Lattimore abandoned the traditional conquest theory – a framework he had previously espoused – which held that both China’s early states and most of its subsequent empires were forged by Eurasian nomadic conquerors rather than indigenous dynamics. The rejection of the conquest theory was a repudiation of extrahuman transportation and pastoralism as forces that led to statehood, and an exaltation of sedentism and grain agriculture instead.
The theory that entrenched Lattimore’s thesis in academia is Robert Carneiro’s circumscription hypothesis, published in the journal Science as ‘A Theory of the Origin of the State’ (1970). Not just conventional narratives, but a wide array of prominent thinkers – including Michael Mann, Jared Diamond, Francis Fukuyama and Yuval Noah Harari – popularised Carneiro’s theory in different guises. Even David Graeber and David Wengrow ultimately remain within this framework.
Drawing on Carneiro’s concept of circumscribed agricultural land, Mann’s The Sources of Social Power (1986) posits ecological and social cages with no ‘escape route’, while Diamond’s Guns, Germs, and Steel (1997) similarly focuses on regions with ‘nowhere to flee’ to isolate the environmental conditions that generate the population pressure needed for the rise of the state. Fukuyama’s The Origins of Political Order (2011), however, is far more direct in delineating the primary conditions for pristine state formation: ‘that population needs to be physically constrained so that it increases in density’ and ‘that subjects cannot run away when coerced’.
When Diamond wrote in Nature in 2002 that agricultural storable food surpluses ‘led to social stratification, political centralization and standing armies’, he was merely rationalizing the Lattimore-Carneiro population-pressure dogma as an ‘autocatalytic’ process. Harari’s Sapiens (2011), with its disease-ridden ‘luxury trap’, Scott’s The Art of Not Being Governed, along with his Against the Grain, and Graeber and Wengrow’s lamentation that ours is a species ‘enslaved to its crops’ all ultimately stem from the same grain thesis.
Indeed, the Lattimore-Carneiro framework relied on a population-pressure model, arguing that agriculture and sedentism triggered overpopulation, forcing the creation of hierarchies and states. However, Carneiro’s circumscription thesis required areas such as Mesopotamia, the Nile Valley and the Peruvian coast to be entirely overcrowded. Instead, empirical settlement surveys revealed that these areas lacked the demographic density to exhaust arable land, with some even experiencing depopulation during early state-formation. Because no population pressure existed to catalyze state formation, archaeological findings invalidated Carneiro’s theory.
Scott’s novelty lies neither in his rhetoric of ‘political crops’, nor in his laser-focused ‘circumscribed ecological niches’ of ‘alluvial or loess soils’, but rather in his theoretical sleight of hand: dynamic climatic circumscription. His fertile alluvial or loess soils mirror Carneiro’s circumscribed agricultural land, though on a minuscule scale, engineered by a millennium-long drought rather than geographic barriers.
Ultimately, Scott repurposes Carneiro’s model of resource concentration – a resource-rich habitat that draws people from surrounding regions – yet he supercharges it with the driving force of drought. In sum, drought – simultaneously reconfiguring the physical terrain into a localized cage and driving populations inward – enables Scott to isolate the minuscule, 250-hectare footprint of Uruk as the circumscribed agricultural land. Scott’s model here is a clever maneuver to salvage the Sinocentric paradigm. That paradigm, as we shall see, owes its formation to Cold War politics and is at odds with archaeological evidence.
*
By establishing mobility as the defining feature of pastoralism, and immobility as that of irrigated agriculture, Lattimore posited both a positive correlation between wealth and power and a negative one between mobility and wealth/power, thus advancing his ‘wealth versus mobility’ thesis. And by asserting that ‘grain, accumulated and stored, was beyond question the standard of real wealth in essentials’, he guaranteed ‘the ascendancy of wealth over mobility’. In this manner, Lattimore not only erased mobility as the state-making force but also established grain as that very force. In fact, Lattimore is the author of the grain thesis, and in his framework, the state emerges as a grain store.
Mobility, thus, emerged not merely as dispersal, but as a mechanism of destitution, rather than a driver of state-building. While Lattimore declared that ‘it is the poor nomad who is pure nomad,’ intellectual successors like the cultural anthropologist Marshall Sahlins observed that a nomad’s wealth ‘is a burden’ that ‘soon poses a contradiction to his mobility.’ Anatoly Khazanov pushed this thesis further, arguing that pastoralism is inherently non-self-sufficient (non-autarkic) or even anti-autarkic, thereby rendering it fundamentally incapable of producing a state.
•
In sharp contrast, Max Weber’s theory provides an idealist framework explicitly formulated to counter evolutionary materialism. In this view, history is driven by great ideas, new revelations, powerful beliefs and groundbreaking inventions – transformative forces that Weber conceptualized under a single term: charisma. ‘Charisma,’ he writes in Economy and Society (1921), ‘is the great revolutionary force’ – ‘the specifically creative revolutionary force of history’.
Charisma – whether it ‘be of a religious, ethical, artistic, scientific, political, or other kind’ – sits at the root of all human institutions, organizations and arts. Consequently, the institutions of politics, religion, art and the sciences, such as the state, the church and academia, are legacies of generations of charismatic or gifted leadership. The state – a creation of military charisma and charismatic warlord conquest – is the most critical of them. As such, every technological breakthrough – from extrahuman transportation to the iPhone – is ultimately a creation of charisma.
However, it is precisely Fried and Service who erased Weber’s great revolutionary force from state-formation as well as history. They co-opted Weber’s framework of political authority but mutilated it, rendering it unrecognizable. ‘Doing some violence to Weber’s thought,’ in Origins of the State and Civilization (1975), Service mapped Weber’s charismatic authority onto ‘egalitarian-segmental societies’, his traditional authority onto ‘chiefdoms’, and his legal authority onto ‘the government of archaic civilizations’ ‘to epitomize very well the leadership’ in those societies.
Thus, Service proscribed Weber’s charismatic and traditional authorities from history and civilization. As for charisma, both Service and Fried unanimously banished it to pre-historic primitivity, to the sphere of the supernatural, or to madness – ‘a charismatic madman who just happens to be the genealogical leader of the largest kin group,’ as Fried himself put it in Evolution of Political Society (1967). In doing so, they not only effectively erased Weber’s principal agent of state-building but also made it exotic, mad, tribal and barbarian, exiling it to Inner Asia. This transformed Inner Asia into both the womb and tomb of military charisma, and Inner Asian empires into the excesses of military madmen.
*
However, it is not just war per se or armed conflict, but conquest – or wars of conquest – that gives rise to the state, which is why the theory is called conquest theory. This model sees mobility or extrahuman transportation as the decisive revolutionary force. Without extrahuman transportation, forming a large society is impossible, and communities are forced to split and disperse, as observed in Amazonia. Ultimately, extrahuman transportation is what enables conquest and state-building.
Because pastoralists possessed extrahuman transportation in the form of herding animals, the conquest theory argues that the state first arose among nomads, who then conquered neighboring farming regions. For this reason, the conquest theory is primarily a theory of nomadic conquest over sedentary farmers. In addition to high mobility, the theory identifies military leadership, organization, discipline, martial skills and a warrior ethos as key cultural factors in the rise of the state, noting that these qualities are highly developed among pastoralists. Undeniably, frequent long-distance migration with large herds under harsh and unpredictable conditions naturally fosters these leadership and martial attributes.
While conquests by equestrian warrior nomads were the most consequential in the rise of the state and civilization, the conquest theory maps a broader historical sequence. It posits a series of conquests over time: first of hunters over cultivators, then of herdsmen over planters and peasants and, finally, of European colonial powers. Conquest theory by no means valorizes conquest; instead, it views it as creating despotic, two-strata class states whose toxic legacies we must confront and overcome. Indeed, conquest theory offers a radically different vision and framework to make sense of the human journey and its historical trajectory. It presents a vision neither of ever-evolving progress nor of inevitability, but equally not of permanent entrapment or doom.
Through this lens, much like conquests, every progressive political, social, economic and cultural achievement of the modern era, just like each conquest of the previous era, stems from a charismatic revolution – be it political, social, economic or scientific – aimed at dismantling the bitter legacies of institutional injustice and natural limitations. From the early foundational shifts of liberal revolutions and constitutionalism, to global decolonization, to human and environmental rights frameworks; and from the Industrial Revolution, to the rise of STEM, to the advent of AI – all are, for better or worse, the fruits of charismatic ideas, individuals, endeavors and movements. Ultimately, it is not the invisible engine of evolution that drives history, but the fire of human agency.
Though the human journey remains a persistent pursuit of freedom, its trajectory is conceptualized as a transition from the despotic, two-strata, class-based ‘State of robbery’ to the ‘Freemen’s Citizenship’ of the future (as Franz Oppenheimer put it in 1914) – a self-governing society – progressing through a series of states, including constitutional ones.
However, the path of progress is neither linear nor consistent. Every step of liberation has been shaped by historical contingencies, facing severe setbacks, systemic backlash and profound failures along the way. Moreover, the achievements of today’s charismatic revolutions routinely become tomorrow’s institutional trap and bulwark: the liberating ideas of one era harden into the systemic barriers of the next. Progress, therefore, remains trapped in a perpetual cycle of revolution and institutionalization. Despite these fractures and constraints, the core drive remains unyielding: charisma – a deeply human, deeply individual, and deeply personal impulse for freedom.
Conquest theory arms us with a framework to not only break free from the Sinocentric paradigm but also to critically re-evaluate human history, fully reclaim our agency, and purposefully chart our own future. Only by overcoming the Sinocentric paradigm and embracing conquest theory can we construct a human history that fully appreciates the significance of the extrahuman transportation outlined at the outset of this essay. Such an account will be more than the new history of humanity that Graeber and Wengrow deemed necessary; it will provide a framework that finally rescues human history from being treated as an anomaly.
https://aeon.co/essays/the-origins-of-the-state-are-not-agrarian-but-pastoralist?utm_source=Aeon+Newsletter&utm_campaign=275adc4208-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2026_11_20&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_-ec77df1527-838110632
Nick Fielding:
Such a breath of fresh air to read this article. I strongly agree with Professor Munkh-Erdene. We can go back much further than the Mongols to substantiate his arguments. The Scythians never built a city, but ruled a huge empire using a mobile leadership model. Even Alexander of Macedon barely spent any time in cities, ruling his empire from the saddle. The Huns and Turks also operated on the same basis for many centuries. Later, as the professor notes, the Mongol rulers of China remained nomadic long after their conquest of Chinese territory, preferring encampments to cities. Lattimore’s blindness to this stemmed from his attachment to Marxist orthodoxy which could never explain pastoralist forms of social organization. Marx himself tried (vaguely) to develop the idea of an ‘Asiatic’ mode of production, but it never explained anything. Others have tried since, and also failed. Now is the time for a new history of the world that develops the theories so eloquently explained by Prof. Munkh-Erdene.
Stephen Cohen:
Professor Munkh-Erdine has hit the nail on the head. His thesis that the root cause of state building was extra-human transportation, i.e., pastoralist and water borne, and not agriculture, was well thought out and documented. His essay is a major contribution to the literature on this subject.
m munn
I am familiar w/ horses but not the history of rulers.
Horses, humans, llamas, or oxen, all require nutritious foods to elevate a subsistence (wild) lifestyle to productive, energy expending one, so high quality, protein rich food/grains would be needed.
It would seem you can’t have one without the other.
Author:
Thanks. That’s exactly what the grain thesis argues. However, the real issue is state-building, not nutrition or how humans and other animals feed. We are talking about human political organization – specifically, the creation of institutionalized violence. Naturally, without a human population, there would be no politics to discuss, but we shouldn’t confuse basic existence with political organization.
Oriana:
It’s still hard for me to think of a Mongolian horde as a major civilizing force. Still, to dismiss the nomads is also a mistake. I suppose that, for a state to be formed, many factors need to exist at the same time, including both means of transportation and a secure food supply. Nor can Weber’s insights into the importance of charismatic ideas be dismissed. Rome conquered Greece, but the power of Greek culture — or call it charisma — guided Rome far beyond crude militarism.
I don’t think we can single out one factor, be it transportation or agriculture, as primary in the development of the modern state. It takes many forces being present and acting together. Nevertheless, I am grateful to the author for having explained the crucial importance of transportation. It's no accident that so many important cities are seaports or river ports -- or that few human inventions can compete in importance with the wheel.
*
HOW COME THE 99% DON’T OVERTHROW THE TOP 1%?
The 99% actually have overthrown the 1% in places like France, Russia, and China. But once the elites were dead, the revolutionaries didn't return to the factories—they became the new 1%.
These uprisings never resulted in a lasting, egalitarian utopia where wealth was evenly distributed. Overthrowing the elite runs into three historical realities.
First, revolutions do not smoothly transfer wealth; they destroy it. You cannot politely ask the ruling class to hand over their assets. Overthrowing the elite requires civil war and the collapse of the existing economic system. By the time the 99% win, the wealth they were trying to distribute—infrastructure, supply chains, agricultural systems, and capital—is often in ruins.

Citizens flee machine gun fire during a street demonstration on Nevsky Prospekt in Petrograd in July 1917
Second, human societies naturally form hierarchies, a concept sociologists call the "Iron Law of Oligarchy." Whenever a massive group of people overthrows a system, they need leaders to organize the rebellion. Following the Russian Revolution, the Romanovs and wealthy capitalists were replaced by the Nomenklatura—a bureaucratic elite who enjoyed private dachas, special grocery stores, and luxury cars while the 99% stood in breadlines. The faces at the top changed, but the unequal distribution of power and wealth remained.
Finally, a revolution is only attractive when the alternative is starvation. In modern capitalist democracies, wealth inequality is high, but the absolute living standard of the bottom 99% is the highest it has ever been in human history. As long as people have access to food, climate-controlled housing, and entertainment, they will not risk catching a bullet in a street uprising. People only flip the chessboard when they have absolutely nothing left to lose.
Modern elites are also insulated by the state's monopoly on violence. The 1% today do not rely on private guards with muskets; they are protected by militarized police forces, surveillance systems, and professional armies. An armed uprising by the general public against a modern government is essentially impossible to win. ~ SepiaGlyphs, Quora
Neil Breakfield:
Excellent take down of what socialist revolution promises but cannot possibly deliver. Just like how at the end of the book Animal Farm, the pigs become indistinguishable from the humans, the leaders of the revolution always become what they overthrow.
Ed T:
The theme in “Animal Farm” is that “All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others”. It is an allegory of the Russian Revolution and the rise of communism and how nothing changed but the faces at the top.
Simon King:
My favorite quote about revolutions is from Simon Bolivar (who knew a thing or two about revolutions)
“He who serves the revolution plows the sea.”
*
PENITENT SINNER OR A FIERY SAINT? MARY MAGDALENE AS A DIVISIVE FIGURE
Mary Magdalene is one of the most significant yet misunderstood figures in New Testament history.
Key Facts About Mary Magdalene
First Witness and "Apostle to the Apostles": She is consistently named in the Gospels as a primary witness to the crucifixion, the first person to find the empty tomb, and the first to encounter the resurrected Jesus, leading St. Thomas Aquinas to dub her the "Apostle to the Apostles”.
The Prostitute Myth: The widespread notion that she was a repentant sex worker or prostitute does not appear in the Bible. It stems from a 591 AD homily by Pope Gregory I, which mistakenly conflated Mary Magdalene with an unnamed "sinful woman" in Luke 7 and Mary of Bethany.
Seven Demons: The Gospel of Luke (8:2) notes that Jesus cast "seven demons" out of her, which biblical scholars generally interpret as a profound physical or spiritual healing rather than a mark of moral failure.
Name and Origin: "Magdalene" most likely refers to her hometown of Magdala, a fishing and fish-processing village on the Sea of Galilee, though some scholars view it as an honorific title meaning “tower".
Financial Supporter: She was part of Jesus's inner circle of followers and materially supported his ministry out of her own resources.
The whole history of western civilization is epitomized in the cult of Mary Magdalene. For many centuries the most obsessively revered of saints, this woman became the embodiment of Christian devotion, which was defined as repentance. Yet she was only elusively identified in Scripture, and has thus served as a scrim onto which a succession of fantasies has been projected. In one age after another her image was reinvented, from prostitute to sibyl to mystic to celibate nun to passive helpmeet to feminist icon to the matriarch of divinity’s secret dynasty.
How the past is remembered, how sexual desire is domesticated; how men and women negotiate their separate impulses; how power inevitably seeks sanctification, how tradition becomes authoritative, how revolutions are co-opted; how fallibility is reckoned with, and how sweet devotion can be made to serve violent domination—all these cultural questions helped shape the story of the woman who befriended Jesus of Nazareth.
Who was she? From the New Testament, one can conclude that Mary of Magdala (her hometown, a village on the shore of the Sea of Galilee) was a leading figure among those attracted to Jesus. When the men in that company abandoned him at the hour of mortal danger, Mary of Magdala was one of the women who stayed with him, even to the Crucifixion. She was present at the tomb, the first person to whom Jesus appeared after his resurrection and the first to preach the “Good News” of that miracle. These are among the few specific assertions made about Mary Magdalene in the Gospels.

Noli me tangere, by Alexander Ivanov
From other texts of the early Christian era, it seems that her status as an “apostle,” in the years after Jesus’ death, rivaled even that of Peter. This prominence derived from the intimacy of her relationship with Jesus, which, according to some accounts, had a physical aspect that included kissing. Beginning with the threads of these few statements in the earliest Christian records, dating to the first through third centuries, an elaborate tapestry was woven, leading to a portrait of St. Mary Magdalene in which the most consequential note—that she was a repentant prostitute—is almost certainly untrue. On that false note hangs the dual use to which her legend has been put ever since: discrediting sexuality in general and disempowering women in particular.
Confusions attached to Mary Magdalene’s character were compounded across time as her image was conscripted into one power struggle after another, and twisted accordingly. In conflicts that defined the Christian Church—over attitudes toward the material world, focused on sexuality; the authority of an all-male clergy; the coming of celibacy; the branding of theological diversity as heresy; the sublimations of courtly love; the unleashing of “chivalrous” violence; the marketing of sainthood, whether in the time of Constantine, the Counter-Reformation, the Romantic era, or the Industrial Age—through all of these, reinventions of Mary Magdalene played their role. Her recent reemergence in a novel and film as the secret wife of Jesus and the mother of his fate-burdened daughter shows that the conscripting and twisting are still going on.
But, in truth, the confusion starts with the Gospels themselves.
In the gospels several women come into the story of Jesus with great energy, including erotic energy. There are several Marys—not least, of course, Mary the mother of Jesus. But there is Mary of Bethany, sister of Martha and Lazarus. There is Mary the mother of James and Joseph, and Mary the wife of Clopas.
Equally important, there are three unnamed women who are expressly identified as sexual sinners—the woman with a “bad name” who wipes Jesus’ feet with ointment as a signal of repentance, a Samaritan woman whom Jesus meets at a well and an adulteress whom Pharisees haul before Jesus to see if he will condemn her. The first thing to do in unraveling the tapestry of Mary Magdalene is to tease out the threads that properly belong to these other women. Some of these threads are themselves quite knotted.
It will help to remember how the story that includes them all came to be written. The four Gospels are not eyewitness accounts. They were written 35 to 65 years after Jesus’ death, a jelling of separate oral traditions that had taken form in dispersed Christian communities.
Jesus died in about the year a.d. 30. The Gospels of Mark, Matthew and Luke date to about 65 to 85, and have sources and themes in common. The Gospel of John was composed around 90 to 95 and is distinct. So when we read about Mary Magdalene in each of the Gospels, as when we read about Jesus, what we are getting is not history but memory—memory shaped by time, by shades of emphasis and by efforts to make distinctive theological points. And already, even in that early period—as is evident when the varied accounts are measured against each other—the memory is blurred.
Regarding Mary of Magdala, the confusion begins in the eighth chapter of Luke:
Now after this [Jesus] made his way through towns and villages preaching, and proclaiming the Good News of the kingdom of God. With him went the Twelve, as well as certain women who had been cured of evil spirits and ailments: Mary surnamed the Magdalene, from whom seven demons had gone out, Joanna the wife of Herod’s steward Chuza, Susanna, and several others who provided for them out of their own resources.
Two things of note are implied in this passage. First, these women “provided for” Jesus and the Twelve, which suggests that the women were well-to-do, respectable figures. (It is possible this was an attribution, to Jesus’ time, of a role prosperous women played some years later.)
Second, they all had been cured of something, including Mary Magdalene. The “seven demons,” as applied to her, indicates an ailment (not necessarily possession) of a certain severity. Soon enough, as the blurring work of memory continued, and then as the written Gospel was read by Gentiles unfamiliar with such coded language, those “demons” would be taken as a sign of a moral infirmity.
This otherwise innocuous reference to Mary Magdalene takes on a kind of radioactive narrative energy because of what immediately precedes it at the end of the seventh chapter, an anecdote of stupendous power:
'One of the Pharisees invited [Jesus] to a meal. When he arrived at the Pharisee’s house and took his place at table, a woman came in, who had a bad name in the town. She had heard he was dining with the Pharisee and had brought with her an alabaster jar of ointment. She waited behind him at his feet, weeping, and her tears fell on his feet, and she wiped them away with her hair; then she covered his feet with kisses and anointed them with the ointment. When the Pharisee who had invited him saw this, he said to himself, “If this man were a prophet, he would know who this woman is that is touching him and what a bad name she has.”
But Jesus refuses to condemn her, or even to deflect her gesture. Indeed, he recognizes it as a sign that “her many sins must have been forgiven her, or she would not have shown such great love.” “Your faith has saved you,” Jesus tells her. “Go in peace.”
This story of the woman with the bad name, the alabaster jar, the loose hair, the “many sins,” the stricken conscience, the ointment, the rubbing of feet and the kissing would, over time, become the dramatic high point of the story of Mary Magdalene. The scene would be explicitly attached to her, and rendered again and again by the greatest Christian artists. But even a casual reading of this text, however charged its juxtaposition with the subsequent verses, suggests that the two women have nothing to do with each other—that the weeping anointer is no more connected to Mary of Magdala than she is to Joanna or Susanna.
Other verses in other Gospels only add to the complexity. Matthew gives an account of the same incident, for example, but to make a different point and with a crucial detail added:
Jesus was at Bethany in the house of Simon the leper, when a woman came to him with an alabaster jar of the most expensive ointment, and poured it on his head as he was at table.
When they saw this, the disciples were indignant. “Why this waste?” they said. “This could have been sold at a high price and the money given to the poor.” Jesus noticed this. “Why are you upsetting the woman?” he said to them.... “When she poured this ointment on my body, she did it to prepare me for burial. I tell you solemnly, wherever in all the world this Good News is proclaimed, what she has done will be told also, in remembrance of her.”
This passage shows what Scripture scholars commonly call the “telephone game” character of the oral tradition from which the Gospels grew. Instead of Luke’s Pharisee, whose name is Simon, we find in Matthew “Simon the leper.” Most tellingly, this anointing is specifically referred to as the traditional rubbing of a corpse with oil, so the act is an explicit foreshadowing of Jesus’ death.
In Matthew, and in Mark, the story of the unnamed woman puts her acceptance of Jesus’ coming death in glorious contrast to the (male) disciples’ refusal to take Jesus’ predictions of his death seriously. But in other passages, Mary Magdalene is associated by name with the burial of Jesus, which helps explain why it was easy to confuse this anonymous woman with her.
Indeed, with this incident both Matthew’s and Mark’s narratives begin the move toward the climax of the Crucifixion, because one of the disciples—“the man called Judas”—goes, in the very next verse, to the chief priests to betray Jesus.
In the passages about the anointings, the woman is identified by the “alabaster jar,” but in Luke, with no reference to the death ritual, there are clear erotic overtones; a man of that time was to see a woman’s loosened hair only in the intimacy of the bedroom. The offense taken by witnesses in Luke concerns sex, while in Matthew and Mark it concerns money. And, in Luke, the woman’s tears, together with Jesus’ words, define the encounter as one of abject repentance.
But the complications mount. Matthew and Mark say the anointing incident occurred at Bethany, a detail that echoes in the Gospel of John, which has yet another Mary, the sister of Martha and Lazarus, and yet another anointing story:
Six days before the Passover, Jesus went to Bethany, where Lazarus was, whom he had raised from the dead. They gave a dinner for him there; Martha waited on them and Lazarus was among those at table. Mary brought in a pound of very costly ointment, pure nard, and with it anointed the feet of Jesus, wiping them with her hair.
Judas objects in the name of the poor, and once more Jesus is shown defending the woman. “Leave her alone; she had to keep this scent for the day of my burial,” he says. “You have the poor with you always, you will not always have me.”
As before, the anointing foreshadows the Crucifixion. There is also resentment at the waste of a luxury good, so death and money define the content of the encounter. But the loose hair implies the erotic as well.
The death of Jesus on Golgotha, where Mary Magdalene is expressly identified as one of the women who refused to leave him, leads to what is by far the most important affirmation about her. All four Gospels (and another early Christian text, the Gospel of Peter) explicitly name her as present at the tomb, and in John she is the first witness to the resurrection of Jesus. This—not repentance, not sexual renunciation—is her greatest claim. Unlike the men who scattered and ran, who lost faith, who betrayed Jesus, the women stayed. (Even while Christian memory glorifies this act of loyalty, its historical context may have been less noble: the men in Jesus’ company were far more likely to have been arrested than the women.) And chief among them was Mary Magdalene. The Gospel of John puts the story poignantly:
It was very early on the first day of the week and still dark, when Mary of Magdala came to the tomb. She saw that the stone had been moved away from the tomb and came running to Simon Peter and the other disciple, the one Jesus loved. “They have taken the Lord out of the tomb,” she said, “and we don’t know where they have put him.”
Peter and the others rush to the tomb to see for themselves, then disperse again.
Meanwhile Mary stayed outside near the tomb, weeping. Then, still weeping, she stooped to look inside, and saw two angels in white sitting where the body of Jesus had been, one at the head, the other at the feet. They said, “Woman, why are you weeping?” “They have taken my Lord away,” she replied, “and I don’t know where they have put him.” As she said this she turned around and saw Jesus standing there, though she did not recognize him. Jesus said, “Woman, why are you weeping? Who are you looking for?”
Supposing him to be the gardener, she said, “Sir, if you have taken him away, tell me where you have put him, and I will go and remove him.” Jesus said, “Mary!” She knew him then and said to him in Hebrew, “Rabbuni!”—which means Master. Jesus said to her, “Do not cling to me, because I have not yet ascended to...my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.” So Mary of Magdala went and told the disciples that she had seen the Lord and that he had said these things to her.
As the story of Jesus was told and told again in those first decades, narrative adjustments in event and character were inevitable, and confusion of one with the other was a mark of the way the Gospels were handed on. Most Christians were illiterate; they received their traditions through a complex work of memory and interpretation, not history, that led only eventually to texts. Once the sacred texts were authoritatively set, the exegetes who interpreted them could make careful distinctions, keeping the roster of women separate, but common preachers were less careful. The telling of anecdotes was essential to them, and so alterations were certain to occur.
The multiplicity of the Marys by itself was enough to mix things up—as were the various accounts of anointing, which in one place is the act of a loose-haired prostitute, in another of a modest stranger preparing Jesus for the tomb, and in yet another of a beloved friend named Mary. Women who weep, albeit in a range of circumstances, emerged as a motif.
As with every narrative, erotic details loomed large, especially because Jesus’ attitude toward women with sexual histories was one of the things that set him apart from other teachers of the time. Not only was Jesus remembered as treating women with respect, as equals in his circle; not only did he refuse to reduce them to their sexuality; Jesus was expressly portrayed as a man who loved women, and whom women loved.
The climax of that theme takes place in the garden of the tomb, with that one word of address, “Mary!” It was enough to make her recognize him, and her response is clear from what he says then: “Do not cling to me.” Whatever it was before, bodily expression between Jesus and Mary of Magdala must be different now.
Out of these disparate threads—the various female figures, the ointment, the hair, the weeping, the unparalleled intimacy at the tomb—a new character was created for Mary Magdalene. Out of the threads, that is, a tapestry was woven—a single narrative line. Across time, this Mary went from being an important disciple whose superior status depended on the confidence Jesus himself had invested in her, to a repentant whore whose status depended on the erotic charge of her history and the misery of her stricken conscience.
In part, this development arose out of a natural impulse to see the fragments of Scripture whole, to make a disjointed narrative cohere, with separate choices and consequences being tied to each other in one drama. It is as if Aristotle’s principle of unity, given in Poetics, was imposed after the fact on the foundational texts of Christianity.
Thus, for example, out of discrete episodes in the Gospel narratives, some readers would even create a far more unified—more satisfying—legend according to which Mary of Magdala was the unnamed woman being married at the wedding feast of Cana, where Jesus famously turned water into wine. Her spouse, in this telling, was John, whom Jesus immediately recruited to be one of the Twelve. When John went off from Cana with the Lord, leaving his new wife behind, she collapsed in a fit of loneliness and jealousy and began to sell herself to other men.
She next appeared in the narrative as the by then notorious adulteress whom the Pharisees thrust before Jesus. When Jesus refused to condemn her, she saw the error of her ways. Consequently, she went and got her precious ointment and spread it on his feet, weeping in sorrow. From then on she followed him, in chastity and devotion, her love forever unconsummated—“Do not cling to me!”—and more intense for being so.
Such a woman lives on as Mary Magdalene in Western Christianity and in the secular Western imagination, right down, say, to the rock opera Jesus Christ Superstar, in which Mary Magdalene sings, “I don’t know how to love him...He’s just a man, and I’ve had so many men before...I want him so. I love him so.” The story has timeless appeal, first, because that problem of “how”—whether love should be eros or agape; sensual or spiritual; a matter of longing or consummation—defines the human condition.
What makes the conflict universal is the dual experience of sex: the necessary means of reproduction and the madness of passionate encounter. For women, the maternal can seem to be at odds with the erotic, a tension that in men can be reduced to the well-known opposite fantasies of the madonna and the whore. I write as a man, yet it seems to me in women this tension is expressed in attitudes not toward men, but toward femaleness itself. The image of Mary Magdalene gives expression to such tensions, and draws power from them, especially when it is twinned to the image of that other Mary, Jesus’ mother.
Christians may worship the Blessed Virgin, but it is Magdalene with whom they identify. What makes her compelling is that she is not merely the whore in contrast to the Madonna who is the mother of Jesus, but that she combines both figures in herself. Pure by virtue of her repentance, she nevertheless remains a woman with a past.
Her conversion, instead of removing her erotic allure, heightens it. The misery of self-accusation, known in one way or another to every human being, finds release in a figure whose abject penitence is the condition of recovery. That she is sorry for having led the willful life of a sex object makes her only more compelling as what might be called a repentance object.
So the invention of the character of Mary Magdalene as repentant prostitute can be seen as having come about because of pressures inhering in the narrative form and in the primordial urge to give expression to the inevitable tensions of sexual restlessness. But neither of these was the main factor in the conversion of Mary Magdalene’s image, from one that challenged men’s misogynist assumptions to one that confirmed them. The main factor in that transformation was, in fact, the manipulation of her image by those very men. The mutation took a long time to accomplish—fully the first 600 years of the Christian era.
Again, it helps to have a chronology in mind, with a focus on the place of women in the Jesus movement. Phase one is the time of Jesus himself, and there is every reason to believe that, according to his teaching and in his circle, women were uniquely empowered as fully equal. In phase two, when the norms and assumptions of the Jesus community were being written down, the equality of women is reflected in the letters of St. Paul (c. 50-60), who names women as full partners—his partners—in the Christian movement, and in the Gospel accounts that give evidence of Jesus’ own attitudes and highlight women whose courage and fidelity stand in marked contrast to the men’s cowardice.
But by phase three—after the Gospels are written, but before the New Testament is defined as such—Jesus’ rejection of the prevailing male dominance was being eroded in the Christian community. The Gospels themselves, written in those several decades after Jesus, can be read to suggest this erosion because of their emphasis on the authority of “the Twelve,” who are all males. (The all-male composition of “the Twelve” is expressly used by the Vatican today to exclude women from ordination.)
But in the books of the New Testament, the argument among Christians over the place of women in the community is implicit; it becomes quite explicit in other sacred texts of that early period. Not surprisingly, perhaps, the figure who most embodies the imaginative and theological conflict over the place of women in the “church,” as it had begun to call itself, is Mary Magdalene.
Here, it is useful to recall not only how the New Testament texts were composed, but also how they were selected as a sacred literature. The popular assumption is that the Epistles of Paul and James and the four Gospels, together with the Acts of the Apostles and the Book of Revelation, were pretty much what the early Christian community had by way of foundational writings. These texts, believed to be “inspired by the Holy Spirit,” are regarded as having somehow been conveyed by God to the church, and joined to the previously “inspired” and selected books of the Old Testament to form “the Bible.” But the holy books of Christianity (like the holy books of Judaism, for that matter) were established by a process far more complicated (and human) than that.
It was not until the fourth century that the list of canonized books we now know as the New Testament was established. This amounted to a milestone on the road toward the church’s definition of itself precisely in opposition to Judaism. At the same time, and more subtly, the church was on the way toward understanding itself in opposition to women. Once the church began to enforce the “orthodoxy” of what it deemed Scripture and its doctrinally defined creed, rejected texts—and sometimes the people who prized them, also known as heretics—were destroyed.
As the sacred books were canonized, which texts were excluded, and why? This is the long way around, but we are back to our subject, because one of the most important Christian texts to be found outside the New Testament canon is
, a telling of the Jesus-movement story that features Mary Magdalene (decidedly not the woman of the “alabaster jar”) as one of its most powerful leaders. Just as the “canonical” Gospels emerged from communities that associated themselves with the “evangelists,” who may not actually have “written” the texts, this one is named for Mary not because she “wrote” it, but because it emerged from a community that recognized her authority.
Whether through suppression or neglect, the Gospel of Mary was lost in the early period—just as the real Mary Magdalene was beginning to disappear into the writhing misery of a penitent whore, and as women were disappearing from the church’s inner circle. It reappeared in 1896, when a well-preserved, if incomplete, fifth-century copy of a document dating to the second century showed up for sale in Cairo; eventually, other fragments of this text were found. Only slowly through the 20th century did scholars appreciate what the rediscovered Gospel revealed, a process that culminated with the publication in 2003 of The Gospel of Mary of Magdala: Jesus and the First Woman Apostle by Karen L. King.
Although Jesus rejected male dominance, as symbolized in his commissioning of Mary Magdalene to spread word of the Resurrection, male dominance gradually made a powerful comeback within the Jesus movement. But for that to happen, the commissioning of Mary Magdalene had to be reinvented. One sees that very thing under way in the Gospel of Mary.
For example, Peter’s preeminence is elsewhere taken for granted (in Matthew, Jesus says, “You are Peter and on this rock I will build my Church”). Here, he defers to her:
Peter said to Mary, “Sister, we know that the Savior loved you more than all other women. Tell us the words of the Savior that you remember, the things which you know that we don’t because we haven’t heard them.”
Mary responded, “I will teach you about what is hidden from you.” And she began to speak these words to them.
Mary recalls her vision, a kind of esoteric description of the ascent of the soul. The disciples Peter and Andrew are disturbed—not by what she says, but by how she knows it. And now a jealous Peter complains to his fellows, “Did [Jesus] choose her over us?” This draws a sharp rebuke from another apostle, Levi, who says, “If the Savior made her worthy, who are you then for your part to reject her?”
That was the question not only about Mary Magdalene, but about women generally. It should be no surprise, given how successfully the excluding dominance of males established itself in the church of the “Fathers,” that the Gospel of Mary was one of the texts shunted aside in the fourth century. As that text shows, the early image of this Mary as a trusted apostle of Jesus, reflected even in the canonical Gospel texts, proved to be a major obstacle to establishing that male dominance, which is why, whatever other “heretical” problems this gospel posed, that image had to be recast as one of subservience.
Simultaneously, the emphasis on sexuality as the root of all evil served to subordinate all women. The ancient Roman world was rife with flesh-hating spiritualities—Stoicism, Manichaeism, Neoplatonism—and they influenced Christian thinking just as it was jelling into “doctrine.” Thus the need to disempower the figure of Mary Magdalene, so that her succeeding sisters in the church would not compete with men for power, meshed with the impulse to discredit women generally. This was most efficiently done by reducing them to their sexuality, even as sexuality itself was reduced to the realm of temptation, the source of human unworthiness.
All of this—from the sexualizing of Mary Magdalene, to the emphatic veneration of the virginity of Mary, the mother of Jesus, to the embrace of celibacy as a clerical ideal, to the marginalizing of female devotion, to the recasting of piety as self-denial, particularly through penitential cults—came to a kind of defining climax at the end of the sixth century. It was then that all the philosophical, theological and ecclesiastical impulses curved back to Scripture, seeking an ultimate imprimatur for what by then was a firm cultural prejudice. It was then that the rails along which the church—and the Western imagination—would run were set.
Pope Gregory I (c. 540-604) was born an aristocrat and served as the prefect of the city of Rome. After his father’s death, he gave everything away and turned his palatial Roman home into a monastery, where he became a lowly monk. It was a time of plague, and indeed the previous pope, Pelagius II, had died of it. When the saintly Gregory was elected to succeed him, he at once emphasized penitential forms of worship as a way of warding off the disease. His pontificate marked a solidifying of discipline and thought, a time of reform and invention both. But it all occurred against the backdrop of the plague, a doom-laden circumstance in which the abjectly repentant Mary Magdalene, warding off the spiritual plague of damnation, could come into her own. With Gregory’s help, she did.
Known as Gregory the Great, he remains one of the most influential figures ever to serve as pope, and in a famous series of sermons on Mary Magdalene, given in Rome in about the year 591, he put the seal on what until then had been a common but unsanctioned reading of her story. With that, Mary’s conflicted image was, in the words of Susan Haskins, author of Mary Magdalene: Myth and Metaphor, “finally settled...for nearly fourteen hundred years.”
It all went back to those Gospel texts. Cutting through the exegetes’ careful distinctions—the various Marys, the sinful women—that had made a bald combining of the figures difficult to sustain, Gregory, standing on his own authority, offered his decoding of the relevant Gospel texts. He established the context within which their meaning was measured from then on:
She whom Luke calls the sinful woman, whom John calls Mary, we believe to be the Mary from whom seven devils were ejected according to Mark. And what did these seven devils signify, if not all the vices?
There it was—the woman of the “alabaster jar” named by the pope himself as Mary of Magdala.
He defined her:
It is clear, brothers, that the woman previously used the unguent to perfume her flesh in forbidden acts. What she therefore displayed more scandalously, she was now offering to God in a more praiseworthy manner. She had coveted with earthly eyes, but now through penitence these are consumed with tears. She displayed her hair to set off her face, but now her hair dries her tears. She had spoken proud things with her mouth, but in kissing the Lord’s feet, she now planted her mouth on the Redeemer’s feet. For every delight, therefore, she had had in herself, she now immolated herself. She turned the mass of her crimes to virtues, in order to serve God entirely in penance.
The address “brothers” is the clue. Through the Middle Ages and the Counter-Reformation, into the modern period and against the Enlightenment, monks and priests would read Gregory’s words, and through them they would read the Gospels’ texts themselves. Chivalrous knights, nuns establishing houses for unwed mothers, courtly lovers, desperate sinners, frustrated celibates and an endless succession of preachers would treat Gregory’s reading as literally the gospel truth. Holy Writ, having recast what had actually taken place in the lifetime of Jesus, was itself recast.
The men of the church who benefited from the recasting, forever spared the presence of females in their sanctuaries, would not know that this was what had happened. Having created a myth, they would not remember that it was mythical. Their Mary Magdalene—no fiction, no composite, no betrayal of a once venerated woman—became the only Mary Magdalene that had ever existed.
This obliteration of the textual distinctions served to evoke an ideal of virtue that drew its heat from being a celibate’s vision, conjured for celibates. Gregory the Great’s overly particular interest in the fallen woman’s past—what that oil had been used for, how that hair had been displayed, that mouth—brought into the center of church piety a vaguely prurient energy that would thrive under the licensing sponsorship of one of the church’s most revered reforming popes. Eventually, Magdalene, as a denuded object of Renaissance and Baroque painterly preoccupation, became a figure of nothing less than holy pornography, guaranteeing the ever-lustful harlot—if lustful now for the ecstasy of holiness—a permanent place in the Catholic imagination.
Thus Mary of Magdala, who began as a powerful woman at Jesus’ side, “became,” in Haskins’ summary, “the redeemed whore and Christianity’s model of repentance, a manageable, controllable figure, and effective weapon and instrument of propaganda against her own sex.”
There were reasons of narrative form for which this happened. There was a harnessing of sexual restlessness to this image. There was the humane appeal of a story that emphasized the possibility of forgiveness and redemption. But what most drove the anti-sexual sexualizing of Mary Magdalene was the male need to dominate women. In the Catholic Church, as elsewhere, that need is still being met.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/who-was-mary-magdalene-119565482/
Oriana:
Since Mary Magdalene was the first person to see the Risen Christ, and became the “Apostle to t he Apostles,” then the reasoning that priests can only be male because the apostles were male loses its validity. Mary’s being an apostle, perhaps even the primary one (“The Apostle to the Apostles”), could be cited as one of the chief reasons that women should be allowed to be priests.
*
99 percent of religious violence around the world happens in the name of Islam
*
*
BROWN FAT KEEPS US WARM
Brown fat burns energy when we are cold. Now scientists are trying to harness its powers to fight obesity and type 2 diabetes.
When the nights draw in, the leaves fall off the trees and the outside world becomes blanketed in frost, many of us will be tempted to reach for the thermostat and crank up the heating. When venturing outdoors, we'll likely wrap up in a scarf and hat, piling on the layers in a desperate attempt to keep warm. Yet being cold and uncomfortable could be the key to improving health and losing weight.
The reason is all down to a special type of fat called brown fat. Unlike white fat, which clings stubbornly to thighs, waists and hips, brown fat burns calories, converting them into heat when we are cold. Some believe that if harnessed properly it could make us thinner. Intriguingly, all we theoretically need to do to activate it is to hop into a cold shower or eat lots of spicy foods and caffeine.
But before you jump into an icy lake or down that fourth cup of coffee, it is worth exploring whether the hype behind brown fat is justified.
How is brown fat different?
When we are born, each of us has plentiful stores of brown fat which act like an internal heater. Babies don't have enough muscle mass to shiver, so they rely on brown fat to convert sugars and fats into heat.
Brown fat cells have a disproportionately high number of mitochondria – the energy producing factories inside cells. But unlike normal mitochondria which produce adenosine triphosphate (ATP) – a kind of universal energy currency the body can use – the mitochondria inside brown fat cells contain a protein called thermogenin, or UCP1, which allows them to convert calories from food directly into heat instead.
"When stimulated, brown fat has the capacity to produce 300 times more heat per unit mass than any other tissue or organ in the body," says Michael Symonds, professor of developmental physiology at the University of Nottingham in the UK.
Most of what we know about this brown fat comes from studies on small mammals such as mice and rats. These rodents have large reserves of it, which helps them keep toasty and warm during the winter months when they go into hibernation.
"For our ancestors, or for small animals like mice, cold temperatures would have been a major threat to survival, so it was advantageous to have a tissue that could convert energy sources into heat," says Paul Cohen, an associate professor at The Rockefeller University, New York, who studies molecular metabolism.
Decades of research shows that, in mice at least, brown fat sucks up sugars and fats from the bloodstream. Brown fat also appears to protect mice from obesity and metabolic diseases linked with weight, such as diabetes and heart disease.
Brown fat in adults
Adult humans are, however, adept at finding other ways to keep warm – turning the heating on, snuggling under a thick duvet or pulling on an extra-warm coat. It was widely assumed that brown fat all but disappeared by puberty for this reason, with the traditional white thigh-hugging fat we are all familiar with taking its place.
And this also meant that most scientists believed it was impossible for brown fat to play a meaningful role in health beyond infanthood. This changed in 2009, however, when researchers from Finland and Sweden showed that human adults not only still have brown fat, but in temperatures below 16C (60.8F), the fat activated and started absorbing glucose and fats from the bloodstream.
Not only that, there was a clear correlation between a person's body weight and their brown fat reserves. Thinner, leaner individuals had more, and obese people less. Those with more brown fat also had higher metabolic rates in the cold. Together, this suggested that brown fat could be a target for the treatment of obesity.
The field received a boost in 2021, thanks to a study by Cohen and colleagues at The Rockefeller University in New York. Cohen and his team examined positron emission tomography (PET) scans of over 52,000 people. They compared people who had no discernible brown fat with individuals who did, finding that rates of type 2 diabetes, heart disease, stroke and high blood pressure were much less common among those with brown fat.
They also found that leaner people were more likely to have brown fat than individuals with obesity.
What's more, people with larger reserves of brown fat also had lower levels of glucose and triglycerides (a type of fat) floating around in their blood stream, improved insulin sensitivity, as well as more of the "good" kind of cholesterol – high-density lipoprotein (HDL) – all signs of a healthy metabolism.
Can brown fat lead to weight loss?
It's not clear whether brown fat is actually responsible for these health benefits, however. The truth is that our bodies are probably too large, and contain too little brown fat, for it to burn through enough white fat to make a meaningful difference to our weight. Most adults have a vanishingly small amount of the stuff – just 0.02 to 300g, or less than 0.5% of the total human body mass.
"Whereas white fat has almost an unlimited capacity to expand – there are some people who have over 100kg (220lb) of white fat – brown fat probably measures in the hundreds of grams at most," says Cohen.
However, it's possible that, while brown fat might not help you shed the pounds, it could still boost your health in other ways. For instance, instead of burning calories, brown fat could help to improve metabolic health – the body’s ability to process and use energy from food effectively. People who have poor metabolic health are unable to clear glucose from their blood quickly, raising their risk of type 2 diabetes. Brown fat could act simply by taking up glucose from the bloodstream, or by secreting hormones that act on other tissues to regulate insulin sensitivity.
"In terms of whole-body energy expenditure, it [brown fat] probably does not play as large of a role in humans as it does in mice," says Cohen. "So my personal feeling, based on the data, is that brown fat activation is not going to be a good means to treat obesity or to lose significant amounts of weight."
"However, the data is much stronger to suggest that activating brown fat might lower glucose levels and improve metabolic health. So, I think if there is going to be a therapeutic side to this, it's much more likely going to be in treating the complications of obesity and aging than in treating obesity per se.”
But how can we activate brown fat, and harness the superpowers it may – or may not – contain? One way is to expose yourself to cold, as uncomfortable as it may be. Think ice baths, cold water swimming, or cryotherapy chambers – a specialized device that exposes the body to extremely low temperatures for one to three minutes to promote healing and wellness. The shock of cold-water immersion causes the body to think it's in danger, activating the fight-or-flight response. This releases the neurotransmitter noradrenalin, which binds to and "activates" brown fat cells.
Susanna Søberg, a metabolic scientist who founded the Søberg Institute in Denmark to promote the health benefits of cold and heat therapy, has spent years studying the effects of cold-water swimming on the human body. In one study, her team compared men who regularly plunge themselves into icy Scandinavian lakes during the winter with men who do not perform this seemingly insane practice.
The participants were given a glass of sugar water, and then two hours later their glucose and insulin levels were measured. The cold-water swimmers were able to clear the glucose from their blood much faster and had better insulin sensitivity. The research showed that just a couple of minutes of exposure to freezing cold temperatures two-to-three times a week was enough to activate brown fat, improve insulin sensitivity, and lower stress.
However, it could be reasonably assumed that people who regularly take icy plunges are also more likely to swim or exercise generally, which could explain their better health.
Cohen's group are also looking into whether the same effects can be found in people who regularly swim in the icy lakes of Minneapolis, Minnesota, in the winter.
"In the winter it's cold enough there that the lakes freeze, so they [the swimmers] often have to cut a hole in the ice to get in," says Cohen.
Boosting brown fat levels
However, it's possible that the same effects could be achieved with cool – but not freezing – temperatures. For instance in a 2014 study, five healthy men spent one month sleeping in a cool room heated to 19C (66F), with just thin hospital clothes and bed linen to keep them warm. After the trial had ended, the men had increased their brown fat volume by 42%. The men's insulin resistance, a key measure of health, also improved. However, once the researchers cranked up the thermostat to 24C (75F), the brown fat disappeared again.
In 2013, meanwhile, researchers in the Netherlands subjected 17 healthy adults to temperatures of 15-16C (59-60.8F) for six hours a day. Just 10 days of this treatment was enough to increase brown fat activity and reduce shivering, with the participants reporting that after the trial they felt better able to tolerate cold.
Cohen's group, meanwhile, are currently looking into whether wearing a "cold vest" for three hours a day could have the same effects. "The cold vest looks almost like a life jacket and it has cold water circulating through it," says Cohen. "The goal is not to have people shivering, but to get to the temperature when they start shivering and then raise the temperature by about two degrees Celsius."
It's possible that turning down the thermostat or jumping in a cold shower could also improve health in a similar way. One study showed that living in a room heated at 14-15C (57.2-59F) was enough to increase the insulin sensitivity of eight type 2 diabetes patients, while a randomized control study from the Netherlands found that people who took a cold shower every day had fewer sick days at work – with just 30 seconds of standing under freezing water enough to provide a benefit.
"Small studies suggest that things like exposure to cold showers may have beneficial effects, although the type of person that might undergo that may be a healthier person anyway," says Symonds. "Most people consider it quite a severe challenge to have a cold shower, even for a short period of time."
So, are there other ways to boost brown fat without becoming unbearably cold?
Symonds' research suggest that caffeine, and specifically coffee, can stimulate brown fat, and encourage it to start burning glucose and converting it into heat. However, other scientists argue that to reap the benefits, you'd need to down 100 cups of coffee a day, an unrealistic amount even for the most dedicated of coffee fan. Capsaicin, a compound found in chilli peppers, has been shown to activate brown fat in mice, and there are signs it could do so in humans too. In one study, 10 men took capsaicin pills every day for six weeks. At the end of the trial, the men who took the pills had greater brown fat activation when subjected to cold temperatures than they had done at the beginning of the trial.
So, should we all be leaving the thermostat alone and embracing the cold weather a little more? Possibly, although if you want a sure-fire proven way to boost your health, there are probably other things to try first. Cohen points to eating a heart-healthy diet; doing regular exercise; making sure your cholesterol, blood pressure and blood glucose are well controlled; and being at or close to a healthy body weight as being most important.
It's also vital to consult a doctor before trying cold-water swimming, as it may not be safe and suitable for everyone. Symonds believes that activating brown fat could play a part in improving health and losing weight, but only alongside other health-boosting lifestyle changes.
"When we published our study on the benefits of caffeine for activating brown fat, I had people writing to me saying I have 10 cups of coffee a day, and I still have a weight problem," says Symonds.
"It's not that the more caffeine you have, the more likely you are to lose weight. Caffeine is one potential factor that can simulate brown fat. But ultimately, it's about having a healthy, balanced diet and having a healthy lifestyle, keeping active, avoiding being sedentary for too long. And I think avoiding processed foods."
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20251128-how-to-boost-your-calorie-crunching-brown-fat-in-the-cold-winter-months
*
CAUSES OF DEATH AMONG MEAT EATERS, FISH-EATERS, AND VEGETARIANS
After adjusting for sociodemographic and lifestyle confounders, fish eaters and vegetarians had 13% (hazard ratio 0.87, 95% confidence interval 0.77 to 0.99) and 22% (0.78, 0.70 to 0.87) lower rates of ischemic heart disease than meat eaters, respectively (P<0.001 for heterogeneity).
This difference was equivalent to 10 fewer cases of ischemic heart disease (95% confidence interval 6.7 to 13.1 fewer) in vegetarians than in meat eaters per 1000 population over 10 years. The associations for ischemic heart disease were partly attenuated after adjustment for self reported high blood cholesterol, high blood pressure, diabetes, and body mass index (hazard ratio 0.90, 95% confidence interval 0.81 to 1.00 in vegetarians with all adjustments).
By contrast, vegetarians had 20% higher rates of total stroke (hazard ratio 1.20, 95% confidence interval 1.02 to 1.40) than meat eaters, equivalent to three more cases of total stroke (95% confidence interval 0.8 to 5.4 more) per 1000 population over 10 years, mostly due to a higher rate of hemorrhagic stroke. The associations for stroke did not attenuate after further adjustment of disease risk factors.
Conclusions: In this prospective cohort in the UK, fish eaters and vegetarians had lower rates of ischemic heart disease than meat eaters, although vegetarians had higher rates of hemorrhagic and total stroke.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31484644
Oriana:
It’s possible that vegetarians have insufficient LDL cholesterol, which is important for building strong cell membranes.
*
WHAT A BABY'S FIRST POO CAN TELL YOU ABOUT THEIR FUTURE HEALTH
Research is unveiling the surprising, lifelong impact of what enters a baby's gut in the days after birth.
It's 2017 and two technicians at Queen's Hospital pathology laboratory in London wait anxiously for the day's mail.
On a good day, this lab might receive 50 individual tightly-wrapped packages, each containing a treasure within – a tiny sample of baby poo, carefully scraped from the nappies of newborn infants by their loving parents.
These technicians are the front line soldiers of the Baby Biome study, which aims to understand how a baby's gut microbiome – the trillions of microbes living in their digestive tract – affect their future health. Between 2016 and 2017, the lab analyzed the poo of 3,500 newborns.
It was a lot of poo. But the results were very revealing.
"It's not until about three or four days after birth that you start to get a really good signature of microbes in the gut, so it takes a couple of days to start colonizing," says Nigel Field, professor of infectious disease epidemiology at University College London (UCL), who leads the Baby Biome project.
"You're essentially sterile when you're born. So it's a pretty extraordinary moment for the immune system, because until that moment, all the body surfaces don't come into contact with microbes."
Every single one of us, once we've passed those initial few days of life, develops a gut microbiome. Scientists now believe this community of bacteria, fungi and viruses play a vital role in our health. As adults they help break down hard to digest fiber and provide the enzymes necessary to synthesize certain vitamins. Simply by being there, they protect us from harmful pathogens, while some even release natural antibiotics to kill off invaders.
And the benefits of having a healthy gut microbiome stretch beyond even this. Emerging research suggests that a well-functioning gut microbiome could protect against conditions like anxiety, depression and even neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's.
The flip side of this coin, though, is that having an "unhealthy" gut microbiome as an adult is linked to a long list of conditions including cardiovascular disease, colorectal cancer, chronic kidney disease, diabetes, inflammatory bowel disease and obesity.
'Yet while scientists have conducted lots of studies into the role that gut bacteria have on adult health, until recently they knew little about their impact during childhood. That has started to change, however.
"The first microbes that colonize a baby's gut are like the architects of the immune system," says Archita Mishra, senior lecturer at the University of Sydney in Australia, who studies the role of the microbiome in early-life immune development. "They help 'train' the body to distinguish friend from foe, teaching immune cells how to tolerate food antigens [and] harmless microbes, and mount defenses against pathogens.”
According to Mishra, the bacterial communities that establish in the first six to 12 months are responsible for allergy risk, how well the child responds to vaccines, and how well the gut barrier – the layer that separates the gut's contents from the rest of the body – functions.
"The first thousand days of life appear to be a window when the gut microbiome leaves an imprint that lasts decades," says Mishra.
Face full of poo
The placenta is widely believed to be a bug-free zone, meaning babies don't have a gut microbiome when they are inside the womb. Instead, babies seem to inherit most of their bacteria from their mother's digestive tract – not their vagina, as previously thought.
"Nature has a very refined method of establishing the gut microbiome in a newborn infant," says Steven Leach, a senior lecturer specializing in the gastrointestinal microbiome at the University of New South Wales, Sydney. "If you think about the birth process, the infant is born head down facing the mother's spine. So looking at anatomy, the baby head is pushing out the contents of the [mother's] intestine. So basically, when the baby's born, they get a face full of poo.”
It appears that gut bacteria start affecting your health almost from the very moment you are born. For example, Field's research on baby poo has shown that having the right gut bacteria in the early days of life could help protect babies against viral infections later in childhood. The team analyzed poos from 600 babies at day four, seven and 21 of life. Some of these babies were followed up again at six months and a year.
"The biggest difference really is the mode of birth," says Field. "So cesarean babies look quite different than vaginally born babies."
This makes sense, as babies born by caesarean section miss out on the "face full of poo" enjoyed by vaginally born infants. Caesarean sections – or C-sections – are of course, a lifesaving and often medically necessary procedure. But the research shows that babies born this way miss out on beneficial bacteria that could protect them from respiratory infection.
The 2019 study found that in the first week after birth one of three main pioneer species usually set up shop in the baby's gut – Bifidobacterium longum (B. longum), Bifidobacterium breve (B. breve) or Enterococcus fecalis (E .faecalis).
"According to which one you get, it sets a trajectory for the other species that then colonize the baby," says Field.
By day seven, vaginally-born babies tended to have either B.longum or B.brevae in their digestive tracts, while babies born via C-section were more likely to be colonized by E. fecalis. The gut microbiome of vaginally born babies tended to match that of their mothers, confirming that bacteria are passed mostly from the mother's gut, not her vagina. Meanwhile, babies born via C-section had more bacteria associated with hospital environments.
"E. fecalis is a bacteria that's associated with opportunistic infection. So if your immune system is not working very well, it can cause disease," says Field.
The researchers found the differences in gut bacteria between vaginally-born and caesarean-delivered babies largely evened out by the time the infant turned one. However, there were signs that having good bacteria from day one gave babies a health advantage. The team tracked over 1,000 of the babies to see if any were admitted to hospital.
"We were able to see that babies whose guts were dominated by B. longum were about half as likely to be admitted for a respiratory tract infection within the first two years of life, when compared to the B. brevae babies and the E. fecalis babies," says Field.
In other words, having B. longum seemed to protect some vaginally-born infants from respiratory conditions. It's possible that the absence of beneficial gut bacteria like B.longum could explain why babies born via C-section have a slightly elevated risk of developing certain inflammatory conditions such as asthma, allergies, autoimmune disorders and obesity, although more work is needed to confirm this.
It's not known why a baby's gut bacteria may protect them from infection, but one leading theory is that Bifidobacterium such as B. longum, or other beneficial bacteria called Lactobacillus, are experts at breaking down complex sugars found in human milk called oligosaccharides. These sugars are a major component of human breast milk, but are indigestible by the infant's own enzymes. B. longum converts the sugars into molecules called short chain fatty acids (SCFAs), which are believed to regulate the immune system – potentially helping the infant fight off infections better.
SCFAs can also help teach the infant's immune system to ignore and tolerate innocuous, harmless stimuli. In other words, they help guide the immune system towards a more tolerogenic immune response.
"In Western societies we're not really exposed to deadly bacteria anymore," says Leach. "So the health problems that we're seeing [in the wider Western population] are more to do with having an overactive immune response."
Bifidobacterium are also thought to help create a gut environment that is more hostile to pathogenic, disease-causing bacteria. Unlike an adult's gut, the intestines of newborn babies are aerobic, meaning they contain oxygen. This is to support the gut as it starts to absorb nutrients for the first time. At birth, the intestines are also neither acidic nor alkaline (they have a neutral pH).
"The problem is that the types of bacteria that could potentially harm a newborn infant like these neutral pH aerobic conditions," says Leach. "Bifidobacteria help by rapidly using up the oxygen and creating an anaerobic environment which drops the pH. This limits the growth of potentially harmful bacteria."
However, scientists are only just at the beginning of understanding how all this fits together. "It may be more nuanced than 'caesarean section is less good and vaginal delivery is better'," says Field. "Not all vaginal-born babies got the bugs which were associated with reduced risk, and not all caesarean section babies got the health outcomes that we were worried about."
Microbe engineering
Nevertheless, the finding raises the question – should we intervene to give babies (and especially babies born via C-section) a helpful microbial boost? "C-sections save lives and so our job is to rebuild the missing microbiome, safely and precisely," argues Mishra.
The question is how. One option sometimes considered is "vaginal seeding", whereby a swab of vaginal fluid is smeared on a newborn's skin and mouth in the hope that beneficial microbes will take root in the baby's gut.
The practice is growing in popularity, yet experts warn it could transfer dangerous infectious pathogens: over a quarter of women are thought to carry group-B strep in their vagina, for example, which could be fatal to an infant. What's more, the 2019 baby biome study showed that the beneficial microbes weren't coming from the mum's vagina anyway.
There are other potential microbiome engineering options too, such as fecal microbial transplants, also called a stool or poo transplant. Here, stool from the mother could be transferred to the infant's gastrointestinal tract. There have been some promising small scale trials, but the practice is not currently recommended.
"At the moment, we don't know whether a mum's vaginal or even fecal microbiome is the right one to give to a baby, and I think there's a risk that it might not do good, and that it could do harm that we don't yet understand," says Field.
Probiotic supplements have been shown to be a safe and effective way to influence gut flora, however. Some clinical trials suggest that they could protect extremely premature or low birthweight infants from necrotizing enterocolitis, a life-threatening intestinal disease that primarily affects premature babies, while other studies indicate they could reduce the risk of preterm birth. However, there is still the question of knowing which bacteria to provide.
"Any changes in establishing a microbiome in an infant should focus on restoring or rectifying the impact that human intervention has had on this process," says Leach. "Vaginal seeding and fecal microbial transplants are essentially just dirty probiotics. You just don't know what's in them, and they carry risk. So probiotics are probably the way to go.”
Mishra also says oral probiotics may be the most practical and safest approach, although notes that results vary widely as each baby's gut is unique.
The future, she adds, likely lies in precision microbiome interventions, guided by a baby's genetic, dietary and immune profile. "Think of it as 'personalized microbial medicine'," she says.
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20251103-what-a-babys-first-poo-can-tell-you-about-their-future-health
*
THE IMPACT OF RECESSION ON HUMAN HEALTH
I first became interested in how changes in the economy impact human health while working on a seemingly unrelated topic — diesel exhaust and lung cancer in truck drivers. I started this research at Harvard as part of the appropriately named study TrIPS, or Trucking Industry Particle Study. At that time, the evidence linking air pollution with diseases like lung cancer was still considered by many to be inconclusive.
It was not until 2012 that the International Agency for Research on Cancer definitively linked diesel exhaust with lung cancer by identifying it as a known human carcinogen.
As a postdoctoral research fellow, I was given the daunting task of developing a diesel exposure profile for thousands of truckers to match with lung cancer outcomes and determine whether diesel might have contributed to their deaths. While we had substantial amounts of data and detailed information on diesel exposure in the recent past, there was very little to go on for the vast majority of these truckers’ work histories, many of whom had decades of experience and exposure on the job.
So I went searching for variables that might be related to air pollution to help reconstruct past trends on how much dirty air these workers might have been exposed to on the job. As a newlyminted economist, I naturally turned to economic data, looking to employment trends in the trucking industry and economy-wide indicators of the business cycle for clues.
I was surprised to learn when I first started digging that economics had a lot to say about the relationship between a bad economy and human health. The most recent cascade of studies began in 2000 when economist Christopher Ruhm published a paper examining the link between mortality, unemployment, and income across the United States. Using more advanced statistical methods than previous studies, Ruhm found strong evidence to support the counterintuitive idea that health actually improves during economic downturns in the form of lower death rates, with the notable exception of deaths by suicide.
He argued at the time that reduced employment and income factor into our ability to consume “bads,” products like alcohol, cigarettes, and excess food. Also, physical activity might increase as people walk more to avoid the cost of gasoline and vehicle upkeep or eat less food (or eat out less often), decreasing obesity rates. As the story goes, the upside of a down economy is that you have less money to do bad things!
Although much of the subsequent research on economic downturns and population health from across the globe corroborated Ruhm’s original findings, other economists have reached the opposite conclusion. Study results vary based on how the data is aggregated (individual, county, state etc.). There are also conflicting results depending on the health outcomes
observed, including various measures of chronic health and disability compared to the overall mortality rates observed by Ruhm.
Some have suggested that the relationship between economic downturns and health has weakened over time and is no longer as relevant as it was in the past. Depending on the circumstances of the particular recession observed, which industries and workers were hurt most, safety net measures in place, and so on, there are ultimately winners and losers in the
health outcomes game.
High levels alcohol abuse as well as suicides, is drawing attention to the stark reversal of health fortunes among middle-aged non-Hispanic White populations in the United States. In one study, researchers estimate that half a million deaths between 1999 and 2013 among middle-aged White Americans could have been avoided had the mortality rate held constant at its 1998 level.
A striking rise in drug overdoses, suicides, and chronic liver conditions related to drug and alcohol abuse represent the lion’s share of the mortality increases; however, this cohort’s lower life expectancy is not mirrored in any other U.S. demographic, age, or ethnicity. Put a bit
differently, a White non-Hispanic American between the ages of 45 and 54 today can expect to live a shorter life than their parents.
The steady year-to-year increase in the mortality rate for this age group over more than two decades makes it difficult to attribute deaths of despair to any one specific recession, economic crisis, or labor market trend. Research highlights the potential roots of mortality in the opioid epidemic, accessibility of prescription painkillers, and addiction as well as the physical, mental, and emotional health fallout related to pain, substance abuse, and disability.
But an important clue linking these deaths back to the job market is the role of education as a risk factor: 90 percent of overdoses in the United States occur in people without a college degree. This group is also more likely to experience “serious mental distress” compared to their more educated peers.
Further tying deaths of despair to the workplace, a recent report on Massachusetts workers identified physically demanding blue-collar work, low-paying work, high job insecurity, and lack of paid sick leave as risk factors in opioid deaths.
As the labor market continues its transition toward a technologically advanced and sophisticated service sector, those without a college degree are left with a shrinking share of the pie. Evidence from the sociology literature has related the increase in deaths of despair and particularly drug overdose deaths with de-unionization efforts at the state level.
Inequality in work conditions has been referenced by some as a drivingforce behind growing health inequities nationwide. Interestingly, the precarity and economic insecurity associated with less-skilled work has been associated with increased physical pain, reduced pain tolerance, and a greater use of pain medication, all of which are important risk factors in
opioid drug overdoses.
And it turns out that it is not only one’s own job insecurity but also those of your colleagues and peers that can impact stress and stress-related health outcomes. A study of manufacturing workers during the Great Recession showed that work stress was elevated for remaining workers in downsized plants compared to workers at plants without a high number of layoffs.
My early research on business cycles and air pollution provided an alternative explanation for improvements to health during economic downturns: When there is less economic activity, there is less air pollution. My work identified that both trucking employment and overall unemployment trends tracked with air pollution at the county level in New Jersey and California, the two states with sufficient historical air pollution data to observe these long-term trends.
In California, the size of the unemployment swings observed there during the 1980s and 1990s impacted air pollution concentrations on the order of 10 to 20 percent over that same period. Similar results were observed for New Jersey, where an available marker of diesel pollution (coefficient of haze or COH) tracked closely with economic indicators between 1970 and the mid-1990s. This relationship was particularly noticeable during the major recessionary periods, where peaks in unemployment were matched with troughs in air pollution.
Reduced exposure to air and other sources of pollution that peak during a roaring economy and wane during a weak one might explain some part of the puzzle of healthier populations during recessions and weaker job markets, but it is certainly not the whole picture. Economists have pointed to a few potential factors, most relying on behavior change and reduced consumption of things that are bad for you like cigarettes and alcohol. The unemployed may also have more time for activities like recreational exercise that are squeezed out by tight work schedules.
Of course, there is a counterargument to all of this. Studies also show that stress levels are up during recessions and mental health suffers, and drug and alcohol abuse may rise even when alcohol consumption itself is, on average, down. When there is less money for cigarettes and alcohol, there may also be less money to spend on healthy foods.
Depending on the scope, scale, and target industries of any given recession, population health outcomes are likely to vary by individual, industry, and location.
While these factors offer potential explanations for the observed health trends during economic downturns, the complexities of the relationship between economic conditions and population health are far from fully understood.
The disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic have introduced new variables that may have significantly altered this historical relationship. In pre-pandemic times, workers were less likely to switch jobs during periods of economic upheaval. Not so during the immediate aftermath and economic recovery period, where workers quit, retired, and switched jobs at
levels deserving of its popular title, The Great Resignation.
Understanding the modifying role of increased labor mobility on patterns of recessions and health is a topic worthy of future research. Another potential game changer is that a pandemic-induced recession is unlikely to make people healthier on an aggregate scale since heightened infectious disease risk is the key driver pulling the economy toward the slump in the first place.
These are just two caveats that suggest new patterns of human health linked to economic trends may emerge within the altered job market, public health context, and economic landscape of the future. Only time will tell.
https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-surprising-impact-of-recessions-on-human-health/
*
ending on beauty:
ST. MARY MAGDALENE PREACHING AT MARSEILLES
Now at the end of her life she is all hair —
A cataract flowing and freezing — and a voice
Breaking loose from the loose red hair,
The secret shroud of her skin:
A voice glittering in the wilderness.
She preaches in the city, she wanders
Late in the evening through shaded squares.
The hairs on the back of her wrists begin to lie down
And she breathes evenly, her elbows leaning
On a smooth wall. Down there in the piazza,
The boys are skimming on toy carts, warped
On their stomachs, like breathless fish.
She tucks her hair around her,
Looking beyond the game
To the suburban marshes.
Out there a shining traps the sun,
The waters are still clear,
Not a hook nor a comma of ice
Holding them, the water-weeds
Lying collapsed like hair
At the turn of the tide;
They wait for the right time, then
Flip all together their thousands of sepia feet.
~ Eileen Ni Chuilleanain
Image: The Ecstasy of Mary Magdalene, the Church of St. John, Toruń, Poland







